By: Sim Sitkin
By the time leaders announce a major organizational change, they’ve often spent months—or even years—studying the problem. They’ve analyzed competitors, customers, technology, costs, and strategy until the need for change feels obvious.
Then they gather everyone together for a town hall, unveil the new direction in five minutes, and wonder why people seem hesitant—or even skeptical—concerning the wisdom of those who are advocating for it.
The usual diagnosis, even from experienced change managers, is that employees resist change. But more often, they resist abandoning a system that still makes sense from where they sit.
This distinction matters. When coaching leaders, my colleagues and I have noticed that many confuse an announcement with an explanation. Announcements typically provide only the broadest strategic rationale for the change and direct people to implement the change. Meanwhile, the necessity and the practical implications of the proposed change are often left inadequately explained.
Consider the typical announcement from an employee’s perspective. The detailed thought and analysis that are relevant to my specific situation—the very details that may well have guided the decision to make a change—are left largely unaddressed. I may need help to understand why the current way of working—which may have been a perfect solution when introduced—no longer fits today’s reality. More explanation can show me why a different approach makes better sense, and what that means for my work. It also makes clear that my situations and needs were considered in deciding what to change and how to make those changes.
That difference is one of leadership, not just change management.
Much of the advice on leading change focuses on the strategic and managerial work of implementation: redefining the vision, redesigning the organization, managing project-related tasks, and measuring adoption. Those are all necessary and critically important for effective change execution.
But they overlook an equally important leadership challenge: establishing the credibility of the people leading the change, demonstrating that employees’ situations and concerns have been taken into account, helping people make sense of why change has become necessary in the first place, and clarifying how the change will affect them.
Without that foundation, the change message may have been disseminated, but organization members may not feel the communication was sincere or informative. They may not have enough information to truly understand and embrace the change.
Explanation boosts credibility
Many leaders assume credibility comes with the position. It doesn’t.
People have to decide whether a leader really has the experience and expertise to offer credible analyses and render credible decisions. Why would they take the risk to follow a proposed change if it is not based on sound information and reasoning? As Kouzes and Posner (2010) put so succinctly in their First Law of Leadership, “If you don’t believe the messenger, you won’t believe the message.”
One of the fastest ways to lose that credibility is to begin prescribing solutions before demonstrating an understanding of the system you’re trying to change.
This often happens when successful leaders join a new organization. Perhaps they were hired because they transformed another organization or successfully implemented a different operating model elsewhere. Naturally, they want to replicate that success—and that may have been why they were hired.
They know their previous organization, and why it succeeded, far better than the one they’ve inherited. But are they willing to learn or do they just want to instruct?
People can recognize this potential disconnect immediately. They may not know the new opportunities, but they do know the history behind today’s processes. They understand the customers, technologies, regulations, capabilities, and relationships that shaped the current system. Before they accept that a different approach is necessary, they want confidence that the leader understands their current realities and not just how things worked in a different place and time.
An obvious question thus cannot be ignored: “Do you really understand and appreciate why we have done things in this way, before you suggest we change it?”
If leaders cannot answer that question convincingly, their recommendations often sound like hollow, imported solutions rather than grounded, informed judgments.
Ironically, some leaders avoid asking questions because they worry it will make them appear uncertain. In practice, the opposite is true. Curiosity signals the leader possesses the confidence, courage, and conviction to demonstrate respect for the expertise that already exists inside the organization. Curiosity shows the desire to gain a deeper understanding of local strengths and weaknesses. It helps a leader explain—not simply declare—why change is necessary.
Credibility isn’t built by having all the answers: it’s built by showing you’ve done the work to understand the problem before proposing the solution. Credibility grows when you are dedicated enough to solving real problems that you welcome new information, challenges, and clarifications because they could help make proposed changes even better.
Why this change, why right now
Most systems exist because at some point, they solved important problems. Often they solved them extremely well, which is why they were retained and built upon—and may have become a fundamental part of the organization’s identity and culture. But that doesn’t mean that they would not benefit from updating—even radical change!
That’s why change can feel threatening. People aren’t just losing a system or practice. They’re losing expertise they’ve spent years developing, a method they may have built themselves, or a way of working that once made the organization successful. Sometimes it has become a key part of their identity.
Leaders can overlook this because they begin the story at the end. They can announce the new structure, technology, strategy, or process with pride and confidence. But they often skip over the homework of fine tuning their work, as well as explicit explanation of the reasoning that led them there.
A persuasive explanation therefore begins somewhere different. It begins with conveying that you understand the value of yesterday’s solution and can also make clear why it no longer fits today’s environment. It includes explaining why continuing with the current approach is becoming increasingly risky.
Only after people understand those answers—and your understanding, your learning, and your insights—does the proposed change begin to feel like a well-reasoned response rather than an arbitrary decision.
The goal isn’t to convince people that the old system was wrong: it is to help them understand why a previously successful solution—one we can all be proud of—has reached the limits of its usefulness, but can serve as a springboard for the next generation solution.
That distinction preserves dignity while creating openness to learning and innovation. It may even be the stimulus for a new sense of pride and aspiration to change.
Recognize and address the reality that organizational change is personal

Even when people agree that change is necessary, one question remains: “What does this mean for me?”
Leaders often answer at the 30,000 foot organizational level when they talk about strategy, market conditions, growth, AI, or transformation. Or they focus on the execution of operational tasks.
But people also need more detail about what changes on Monday morning, so they can anticipate what will happen to them. What will they and their teams have to do differently? Where will current strengths and expertise become weaknesses and knowledge gaps? What new skills will they need? How will this impact their clients, their jobs, and the future? Will they have to let go of some of their favorite parts of their job and organizational relationships?
People make sense of organizations locally and personally. Finance needs to understand what all of this means for finance. Operations needs to understand what it means for operations. Sales needs to understand what it means for customers.
The same explanation rarely works equally well for everyone because different groups experience the same organizational decision or change differently.
Change is also more familiar than it was a few decades ago. So people know what some of the risks are, through their own observations and experiences. They know that change typically creates winners and losers. Sometimes a change genuinely benefits one function more than another. Sometimes one group absorbs more disruption so the organization as a whole can become stronger. Is that disruption a source of resentment or of pride? That is a key leadership challenge during times of change.
Leaders should explain those tradeoffs honestly. And help people cope with both positive and negative changes in a constructive, fulfilling way.
People generally tolerate difficult but well-understood realities better than unexplained ones. What they resist is feeling that their concerns have been overlooked or ignored.
When leaders demonstrate that they understand and are willing to address what different groups are gaining, losing, and worrying about, they communicate something deeper than information. They communicate respect, caring, and understanding.
Explanation sparks learning
Leading change is often described as persuading people to adopt a new way of working.
A better description is helping people evolve, adapt, and learn their way into a different future.
Leaders may be able to secure compliance through authority. But compliance alone rarely produces successful transformation. Lasting change requires people to recognize new opportunities, address new problems, exercise judgment, and adapt as circumstances evolve.
No significant organizational change unfolds exactly as planned. Teams have to be willing to experiment and allow processes to evolve as unexpected obstacles emerge. Some ideas succeed immediately; others fail and must be refined. Learning through intelligent experimentation isn’t a sign that the change is off track—it’s how meaningful change takes hold.
That kind of adaptation is only possible when people understand why the change is happening, not just what they’re expected to do. When they understand the rationale, they are more equipped operationally, technically, and emotionally to make sound decisions even when situations arise that they and their leaders never anticipated.
Conclusion
By the time leaders announce a major change, they’ve usually already made sense of why it’s necessary. Everyone else is just beginning to understand.
That’s why explanation is not simply another managerial communication task. It is a core leadership responsibility to exercise influence versus wielding authority. When leaders help people make sense of the rationale for change, people can embrace the new direction and contribute to making the change successful.
Leaders don’t inspire this commitment by announcing a different future. They foster it by helping people understand why a different future has become desirable—or even essential.
Sim Sitkin is the CEO and Founder of Delta Leadership and co-creator of the Six Domains of Leadership Model and SDLS 360° Assessment. He is Duke University’s Michael W. Krzyzewski University Distinguished Professor of Leadership and Faculty Director of Duke’s Center on Leadership and Ethics. He has spent over 25 years studying what behaviors create influence for leaders.

